Monday, April 14, 2008

A PASSAGE TO INDIA

E.M Forster’s A Passage to India opens with a vivid description of Chandrapor, a town in India and the setting of the book. Being interested in cultures and other parts of the world I enjoyably began creating Chandrapor in my mind. The town is a mix between new and old. Ancient Indian temples mix with early 20th century buildings and locals continue to enjoy traditional customs such as smoking hookah in the afternoons while also conforming to British styles of clothing and manner. Chandrapor is a melting pot of Indian and British culture. Unfortunately, due largely to the elitist attitudes of the British inhabitants of India, there still remains a visible division between the two peoples. Although both Indians and the English live in Chandrapor, they do not live among one another. There is strict class separation to ensure that the British citizens maintain superiority over their Indian neighbors. Perhaps because I had just returned from the Holocaust museum in Washington D.C, this fact of class separation struck a nerve. In the eyes of the British the Indians are not people like themselves or other Europeans but rather subjects of a weak culture that must be controlled by a strong one. Indians may not attend the club or play polo or speak to an Englishman as an equal. This elitist view creates tensions between both peoples, some of whom are characters in the book.

When Mrs. Moore enters the Mosque where Aziz is praying she is greeted with furious and upset shouts. Aziz believes that she is wearing her shoes into the mosque because she is British and therefore has no idea of Muslim rules. His misjudgment was probably also caused by the fact that a group of Englishwomen had stolen his Tonga earlier and the fact that the ruling power looks down on him in general because he is Indian. I feel that Aziz is one of those hardworking people – he is a doctor – who wants to be rewarded for his work and kindness but it has not yet come. He wants to be accepted in British culture and tries to impress the English but he will always be just another Indian in their eyes. For Aziz, Mrs. Moore and Ms. Quested are a way for him to enter into the British class because these women want nothing more than to experience the real Indian culture and people. Mrs. Moore and Ms. Quested, both newcomers from England want to see India firsthand and escape from the pompous society they have lived in for most of their lives.

Ronny Heaslop, the British magistrate of Chandrapor, is the perfect example of the stereotypical British ruler in India. To him, Indians are subjects that must be tolerated but that will never be assimilated to British culture. After learning that his mother and fiancĂ© were alone with Aziz at Mr. Fieldings’ home he forbids the two from talking to any more Indians. He has seen all the types of Indians he proclaims and therefore knows all of their tricks in both words and actions. He is not a cold-hearted individual but years of keeping the peace in Chandrapor have led him to be a much sterner individual than he was in his past.

I look forward to continue reading this book because the British occupation of India has always interested me. Basically any story about travelers experiencing a new culture or different world captivates me because I have traveled the world and share their curiosity and thirst for knowledge. The only difficulty I think I will have with this book is remembering who certain Indians are because of their names – for example, Mahmoud Ali makes me want to say Muhammed Ali. (619)

2 comments:

LCC said...

jonny, I posted a beautifully written, heartfelt response to your blog, which didn't appear when I clicked the button, so now I'm so bummed I can't begin to recreate it. Check with me and I'll try to remember what I wrote.

Bummer, dude.

LCC said...

OK, I'll try again (briefly). What I said last time was that I'm glad you like the subject of the novel (colonial occupation), that the misunderstandings and false judgments occur on both sides, that the British come off as more smug and arrogant and therefore less sympathetic (except for Mrs. Moore, who is conspicuously new to the region), and that I thanked you for reminding me of the characters' names since it's been a few years since I read it.