Sunday, January 20, 2008

Old Gregor

Gregor has been the sole provider for his family since his father stopped working about five years ago. He must work to pay off his father’s debt and support his family while everyone else accepts his earnings without contributing any money of their own. Understandably, his mother, affected by her asthma, cannot be expected to work but both his father and sister, Grete, are quite capable of earning money for the family. Gregor’s family has become so reliant on him that they have become spoiled and lazy. Instead of caring for Gregor after his transformation the family sees him as a disgusting annoyance and is only satisfied when he is dead.

Gregor’s father and sister are the two other members of the family that could work but refuse to because Gregor is able to support them. Instead of continuing to work to pay off his debt, Gregor’s father gives the problem to his son. Understandably, Gregor accepts his father’s debt because it is his duty, as a young healthy man, to care for and support his father. After Gregor’s transformation the father worries about paying for food, the apartment, and his debt. Only when Gregor is physically unable to work does the father decide that he must get a job to support the family. If the father can work now then what prevented him from working years earlier? The answer is that he had a son who could work while he relaxed in the apartment. Not once does the reader encounter a passage that shows the father being thankful or gracious for Gregor’s work ethic over the years. In the father’s mind Gregor was a provider but since he is now a bug he is useless to the family. Furthermore, I felt that the father was upset that he had to work as a bank messenger after Gregor’s transformation. It felt as though he was angry that Gregor’s inability to work meant that he had to.

Gregor’s sister, Grete, is also spoiled by her brother’s donations to the family and finally cracks under the pressure of working. Grete is able to sleep in late, lounge around the house, and practice the violin all day because she can really on her brother to earn her a living. Perhaps her charming demeanor is only there because she has never had to struggle a day of her life. After Gregor’s transformation, her kindness begins to fade. At first she brought Gregor a smorgasbord to choose from, then a little less and less, until finally nothing was given to him to eat. Her work, not nearly as difficult as her brother’s work was, forces her to become another provider for the family. After years of only receiving benefits rather than earning them herself, Grete becomes frustrated and finally upset that Gregor can no longer make her life comfortable. In her anger she persuades her parents to stop believing that that “thing” is part of their family and ultimately causes Gregor to die of depression.

After Gregor’s transformation the rolls in the family are reversed. Gregor now becomes “the pest” that the family takes care of; he is no longer the provider and they are no longer the recipient’s of his generosity. Unlike Gregor however, the family becomes tired of supporting him and decides that everyone would be better off if he were gone. Gregor never left his family yet they are leaving him to literally rot away in his room. After years of free meals and comforts the family cannot cope with Gregor’s transformation not because he is a huge bug but because he is a huge bug that cannot give them money to live off of. Even at the end of the story the parents’ first concern is finding a good husband – therefore a wealthy man – for their daughter to marry. Being spoiled and having greed for money prevents Gregor’s family from caring for him during his life as a bug. (658)

Monday, January 14, 2008

What is Up With Religion?

In The Death of Ivan Illyich, Ivan must endure the tortures of his imminent but prolonged death. As he is lying in his bed, Ivan begins to ask himself several deep thought questions concerning his death. He wonders where he will be when he is no more, how death will feel, and ultimately what is responsible for his death. I connected with these questions as I read and started to ponder, just as Ivan ponders, about life, death, and God.

I feel that life is a blessing bestowed upon us by God to quite simply see what we do with it. It is never shown that Ivan is a religious man when he is in good health and only when death approaches does he begin thinking of an afterlife. I on the other hand have often thought, “Where will I go when I die?” The answer is either Heaven, Hell, or maybe I will be reincarnated into a cricket. A coffin is not an answer. If life is lived only for those seventy or eighty years and then that’s it, well then what was the point of living in the first place? I believe that life’s challenges are presented for us to overcome and perhaps even eliminate. Disease, war, poverty, racism, all of these troubles are placed in front of us to allow us to make a decision, whether it is right or wrong. There must be evil for good to prevail over. It is impossible for me to believe that our perfectly functioning world, the home of millions of thinking, feeling people, was made by chance. Since Ivan never thought about death before, while he was living, he is petrified with terror when it finally comes. During his life he had never asked himself those big questions involving Heaven, Hell, or a Creator. Religion is not even brought up until the very last pages of the story. Only after receiving the blessing from the priest does Ivan find an answer to why he must die now. His new found belief in God gives him the confidence to accept death, therefore eliminating his suffering, and the ability to be comforted by “the light.”

In today’s world it is difficult to believe religious scriptures, written thousands of years ago, proclaiming there is a God. Since there are several Gods, including Buddha and Shiva, which one is the true God? In my opinion, anyone of these people could be the one true God, while just as easily none of them could be. Strict religion, I believe, is an invention created by man to control people. I do not think God would create hundreds of religions to have us fight over and use to suppress people’s lives. Instead, I believe that simply being a good person – charitable, kind, helpful, etc. – pleases God. Ivan Illyich exemplifies my idea because he was not religious but he was a good individual. Perhaps he yelled at his wife and grew frustrated at times but his true character was one of an honest man, who enjoyed his peaceful life. At his death, he finally realizes that he must apologize for his actions in life that were not good in order to find peace in death.

The Death of Ivan Illyich begins as a slow story without having any relationships to religion and turns into a story in which religion is of utmost importance to the protagonist. Ivan’s outlook on life, death, and God makes the reader delve into his or her deepest thoughts concerning these three topics. When I finished the story I could not stop thinking about Ivan’s original view of death as a black end and his latter view of death as a part of life that God forces upon us to have us reflect and learn from our experiences. (634)