The friendship that both Mrs. Moore and Mr. Fielding share with Aziz is the only relationship between an Indian and an English person that I have noticed so far in the book. Crossing social boundaries is not an easy task to accomplish for either British subjects living in India or the locals of Chandrapore. As I mentioned in my last blog, the power that the British government and the British people have over the local Indians intimidates the majority of the local population. Aziz is able to overcome his fear of insulting or disgracing himself in the company of Mrs. Moore and Mr. Fielding because these two characters truly appreciate the culture and customs of the people of Chandrapore. Although Mrs. Moore is less knowledgeable of Indian customs and less experienced in dealing with the people she, like Mr. Fielding, is able to put aside her bias and become Aziz’s friend.
After her initial meeting with Aziz at his mosque, Mrs. Moore accepts an invitation to explore the Marabar caves with Aziz as her guide. Aziz had hoped that both Mrs. Moore and Mrs. Quested, who also went on the expedition, had forgotten of his original invitation to visit the Marabar caves. Aziz had offered to take the two women to the caves simply during a casual conversation but his fear of having to organize the entire event and the possibility of disappointing two English ladies prevented him from going through with the plan. Luckily – at least for the women – Mrs. Moore’s constant chatter about still wanting to see the caves reached Aziz who decided to finally organize a trip to the famous site. Mrs. Moore encouraged Aziz not to worry about their comfort during the trip and assured him that they would be perfectly satisfied with whatever he decided to do. These words of encouragement made Mrs. Moore more of a human being rather than a superior English person in the eyes of Aziz. When Ronny ordered her not to talk to any more Indians during her stay in the country, Mrs. Moore replied that she really liked Aziz for being a friend in a foreign land. Unlike the way she treats Antony, her personal servant, or any of the other locals Mrs. Moore interacts with Aziz on an equal footing by asking questions reserved for friends and speaking as if she were among a group of Englishmen at the club. It seems that Mrs. Moore’s friendship will help Aziz evade prison after the final decision at his trial.
Mr. Fielding is the best English friend that Aziz has because he does not enjoy the scene at the club nor does he expect any special treatment from the locals just because he is English. When Aziz falls ill and is talking with his friends in the hospital, Mr. Fielding stops by to check how he is doing. Even as the only white person in the room, Mr. Fielding talks friendly and casually with Aziz and even gets into a discussion about religion. He reveals that he is an atheist, to the shock of Aziz’s friends who are Hindu or Muslim, but is not intimidated by the waterfall of questions this attribute creates. Aziz even shows Mr. Fielding photos of his deceased wife, something that can only be done between “brothers”. Aziz is comfortable enough with Mr. Fielding to accept him as a brother because he has so far treated Aziz with such casualness and simple manner that can only exist between friends. Mr. Fielding agrees to help Aziz with his trip to the Marabar caves and although he misses the train for the expedition he helps Aziz when he returns to Chandrapore as a suspected criminal. Mr. Fielding is the only Englishman to speak in defense of Aziz because he believes that it would be impossible for a man as kind and caring as Aziz to assault another human being – whether Indian or English.
I believe that the friendship Mrs. Moore and Mr. Fielding have with Aziz is the only example of English persons living comfortably with Indians that I will see in A Passage to India. The environment is too hostile for the majority of English subjects to all of a sudden accept the local population as equals, as was the case when Mr. Fielding proclaimed Aziz’s innocence in front of a crowd at the club. Perhaps the greed of the English is just too much to allow these two peoples to live harmoniously side by side. (749)
1 comment:
Good idea about overcoming the obstacles to friendship. And yet the caves scene shows that even those good intentions get lost when fear and panic take over. What the heck did happen out there anyway?
Post a Comment