Sunday, February 3, 2008

Where is Justice?

In our class discussion of Antigone a key topic that came up for debate was how law is used to control the population and promote justice. After class I continued to ponder about Antigone’s role in the pursuit of justice, as well as Creon’s role in upholding the law. Both of these characters offer the reader a different perspective on how the law may be interpreted and perform actions conforming to that interpretation. Antigone believes that since Polynices is her brother he deserves a royal burial whereas Creon, as king of Thebes, sees Polynices as a traitor to his family and city and therefore only deserves the pleasure of rotting on the battlefield. I can relate to both of these characters’ decisions in the story because I too have experienced the desire to bend the rules for family and friends, while also experiencing the unforgiving rules of a superior.

Like Antigone, I will always love and care for my family regardless of what anyone of them might do. Although Polynices is labeled as a traitor, Antigone still regards him as the brother, the native born Thebian, whom she grew up with. Although he took arms against his native city, Polynices is still a blood related member of the royal family so, in Antigone’s eyes, he still deserves a royal burial. I completely sympathize with Antigone in this situation because I have two older siblings whom I could never turn my back on. If my older brother, Christian, tried robbing a bank only to end up in jail I would still consider him my brother because a criminal act would not erase the fact that we share the same last name or that the same blood flows through our veins. Another, less intense example, is that I would let my family and friends cut to the front of the line even if it upset other people because these two groups of people are important to me. I believe Antigone is thinking the same way when she decides to bury Polynices against Creon’s will. Polynices is important to her; he is family so his burial becomes a top priority even though it means breaking the law. Issues like the one between Antigone and Polynices create problems with laws that are read only as black and white.

As king of Thebes, Creon must strictly interpret the law in order to maintain order and discipline within his city. Polynices is a traitor; traitors either die or get exiled. If Creon were to start making exceptions for every citizen of Thebes there would be complete chaos. In a leader’s eyes the law must be seen as black and white in order to ensure stability and order. A perfect example of Creon’s position in today’s world is the job of Mr. Fitzgerald. “Mr. Fitz” memorizes “the laws” of the PCDS athletic manual and then enforces them without exceptions. Although I am a member of the lacrosse team, I may not do anything related to lacrosse until 4 o’clock when my coach arrives on the field. I cannot stretch on the field, I cannot play catch on the field, I cannot save a kid being attacked by wolves if he is on the field. This seems extreme to me but I am just a student so it does not matter what I think. Mr. Fitzgerald’s methods may seem a bit over the top but they ensure that everyone is safe, supervised, and accounted for; if I am upset it does not matter because my safety, not my enjoyment of school, is important. If I am safe I cannot be hurt so the school cannot be sued. But I digress; basically a leader must have one law for everyone to ensure order even if it means upsetting a minority of the population.

The laws of today’s society attempt to promote justice by hearing testimonies and deciding by a majority decision if the accused is truly guilty. People in Antigone’s position, who broke the law to save their friends or family, enter courtrooms all the time. Sadly true justice in today’s court system can be replaced with the justice that can be bought or threatened. People like Creon, who follow the rules blindly, also exist in today’s world. The issues of what is right and what is wrong considering the law or how the law should be interpreted will never be solved. People will continue to fight for their loved ones while judges and leaders will continue to define the law in order to maintain order. (760)

3 comments:

yeah said...

I agree that I would do just about anything for my family members and that the powers that be in our school are a bit too strict in certain areas much like Creon is. Rebelling is exciting, but the order brought about by rules and law are very important too as long as there is room for a bit of bending.

Eric

Dave said...

JLo-
I must say I am deeply impressed with your incredible insight and comprehension of this story. Your comments in class reflect those in your blog: well thought out, clear, and relevant (mostly) to the story at hand. GJ.

LCC said...

Jonny--while I can't quite imagine older bro Christian pulling a Jesse James--although both did spend time up in Minnesota, but Jesse James was in Northfield, not St. Paul or wherever St. Olaf is--and I haven't seen all that many hungry wolves on the lacrosse field this year, you do manage to convince me that the decision between showing favoritism to friends and family and applying the rules equally to everyone isn't as clear-cut or easy as it might at first seem. Yeah.