Sunday, October 7, 2007

Objective View

Upon starting Tim O’Brien’s “The Things They Carried,” I immediately thought that the story would be a dull, lengthy description of an American platoon in Vietnam. The constant lists of equipment and items that the soldiers carried seemed to solidify my assumption. By the end of the story however, my opinion had changed. Although “The Things They Carried” is a lengthy description of a group of American soldiers, it is by no means dull. I feel that the specific details of the characters’ physical and emotional attributes force the reader to view the soldiers in an objective manner.

In my opinion, Tim O’Brien writes his story as a scientist would describe the habits of a pack of wolves or a clan of chimpanzees. The narrator lists the weights of the soldiers’ weapons, “A single round weighed 10 ounces...the M-60 weighed 23 pounds unloaded (10).” The description of the weapons’ weights reminds me of those naturalists on The Discovery Channel who describe the various weights of a lion’s kill or the average size of a gorilla. I could also not help but think of the American platoon as a pack of wolves being studied in the wild. Each soldier is unique, just like each wolf is in a pack. When scientists study wolves they tend to recognize a specific one by a certain marking or habit it has. Rat Kiley carries “a canvas satchel filled with morphine and plasma (9)” so he is identified as the medic of the group. Henry Dobbins, “[a]s a big man (10)”, carries the heaviest load, uses the M-60 heavy machine gun, and therefore provides cover for his platoon. Since the description of these two characters is done in a specific way, listing their items and physical attributes, it relates directly to a scientist’s description of a wolf. The narrator, just like a scientist, also tries to describe the emotional side of the soldiers.

Whenever a wildlife expert studies a group of animals, he or she always uncovers how each individual in the group thinks. The narrator’s description of Jimmy Cross’s feelings for Martha gives the reader a chance to see the turmoil occurring inside his head. He knows Martha does not love him, yet he constantly pretends that she sends him love letters. The narrator unveils Kiowa’s thought process when he tells the reader how he had reacted to the death of Ted Lavender. We, as readers, also learn that Mitchell Sanders provides the dry humor with his constant “morals”. Revealing the thoughts of the soldiers creates a more personal story. Providing the reader with not only the physical attributes but also the mental attributes of the soldiers allows us to feel a human connection with them; similarly to how humans tend to relate to animals, when we see how similar their actions are to ours.

I believe that it was an excellent decision to write “The Things They Carried” as a third person, objective narrative. Although the descriptions of weight become tedious the other descriptions of the soldiers themselves are interesting. As I read, I felt like I was watching these men from a distance and taking notes on how they interacted with each other and the environment. The fact that they are human does not create any stronger a sense of connection with them. The reader could relate to them if they were wolves or gorillas in the wild. The only reason we relate to the soldiers is because of their interactions with each other and how they think; the physical attributes, in the end, are unnecessary. (593)

1 comment:

LCC said...

Jonathan, I like your analogy between the story and a scientific observations of organisms in their native environment. And as you point out, the scientist in question is not only a naturalist but a psychologist as well. You have a good knack for finding original ways to describe your thoughts.

Hope you had a good class trip--I'll see you Monday.