Friday, September 14, 2007

"Teenage Wasteland"

During our class discussion of “Teenage Wasteland” the question of who is to blame for Donny’s current lifestyle aroused several responses from my peers and me. For several students Daisy’s lack of confidence and her constantly lagging self-image inhibited her from positively influencing her son. Her lack of confidence is evident when, during the meeting with Mr. Lanham, she is “clutching her purse…..sit[ting] before this principal as a delinquent parent….unseeing and uncaring (par. 2).” Nevertheless there are several more examples which prove Daisy not only has courage but also the desire to help her mislead son improve. As Donny works on his homework she sits next to him, encouraging him along the way (par. 4). Daisy also recalls how often she had “told Donny he had talent, was smart, was good with his hands (par. 13).” Obviously Daisy cared and continues to care for Donny but her hidden courage is only revealed at the end of the story when she refuses to send her son back to Cal’s “tutoring service.” She no longer allows others to influence her decisions. Cal had not been her idea to begin with and Daisy now realizes that, as Donny’s parent, she is responsible for his upbringing not some hired hand. It is still difficult to say whether Daisy is solely responsible for Donny because it seems she did all that she could have and there were several other negative influences in her son’s life.

I believe Calvin Beadle, or Cal, to be the worst influence in Donny’s life and perhaps the reason Daisy’s son decides to run away. At first Calvin seems like he would be an effective tutor. He acts like one of those adults that the kids respect and obey yet at the same time are able to talk or hangout with. Unfortunately, Cal does not act as a positive mentor because he himself wants to be a un-caged teen spirit, free of rules and oppressive institutions. At Cal’s Donny is “alight and full of interest’ but once he returns home, “Donny doe[sn’t] act much different. He still seem[s] to have a low opinion of his parents (par. 34).” It is important to realize that Donny continues to dislike his parents “controlling” attitude because Cal is continually feeding him illogical and untrue facts about them. Cal’s irrational logic becomes evident when he tells Daisy, “I wouldn’t be surprised to learn the school was in on it (par. 99),” after he mentions that Donny was expelled for hiding beer in his locker. He places blame on the school when Donny is obviously the only one responsible for this dilemma. What is most destructive however is Cal’s false image of friendship. He builds up this impression of loyalty and respect, which makes Donny feel great, only to let it all crumble away when Daisy refuses to continue using Calvin’s services. He even admits that he had made no headway with Donny because Donny was “emotionally disturbed (107).” I believe the unexpected betrayal of Calvin is what finally led to Donny’s decision to run away. Donny is already upset with school and uncomfortable in his own home, so the shock of discovering Calvin to be a fraud and liar drove him over the edge.

Although these two characters play major roles in Donny’s life, Donny himself must not be forgotten as the key contributor to his own development. I believe that everyone is responsible for his or her own actions. The individual is ultimately responsible for his or her decision, regardless of the affect outside influences may have had on him or her. Although Donny’s parents are far from perfect, they still taught him right from wrong and good from bad. Daisy had always encouraged her son when he was younger (par. 13). Perhaps Donny is still just too immature to realize that Calvin is the true failure, not his parents. His parents work hard to raise a family while Calvin drifts through life, scorning his “controlling” past. Although his mother and Calvin influence him in opposite ways, Donny makes the unwise decision to hide beer in his locker (par. 90). He even tries to blame another kid or the school for the incident. He also makes the choice to run away, a decision neither Calvin nor his parents would have agreed with. This act of cowardice infuriated me because I have always been taught that when life gets tough you must face it head-on. Therefore I believe that Donny, and Donny alone, is to blame for his final resolution to rid himself of the past. (761)

1 comment:

LCC said...

Jon,
You say, "Unfortunately, Cal does not act as a positive mentor because he himself wants to be a un-caged teen spirit, free of rules and oppressive institutions." Does that mean you thing being an uncaged spirit and freeing oneself of rules and oppressive institutions is not in a teenagers best interests? I'm not disagreeing with you, just saying that it strikes me as a somewhat surprising thing to hear from, well, a teenager.

So, an interesting blog. You are not the only one to take a rather dim view of Donny in the story, again surprising, perhaps, given the tribal affiliation age often confers on us.